Saturday, May 14, 2011

CD Extraction

With this article I'd like to tackle an issue, which always makes me feel odd
when thinking about it.

"CD Extraction"...

... do I really have it 100% under control ...

... after hundreds of rips and years of active involvement in Computer based audio !?!?!

I just read two articles in the latest issue of the german audio magazine  "Stereo". Stereo is one of the biggest, if not the biggest of its kind over here in Germany.
I do think they got quite a good reputation in the market. 

This month (05/11) Stereo stuck their heads into Computer CD-drives and extraction software to compare the results generated by the tools and drives.

The real interesting thing about it was the result of it.
The soundquality ranking of extraction results on different drives and different software in particular - got my full attention.
As a matter of fact according to Stereo, drives make a difference and tools make a difference on soundquality too - and they are not talking about subtle differences if you look at the SQ-ranking. There are drives going as low as 88% (SonyOptiArc DRX-S 77 U) and extractions tools as low as 94% (EAC!!!!) on the SQ ranking.

Guess what. EAC - was the worst of all.

Do I have a reason to question that Stereo Article, assumimg somewhat professional test-cases and setups ( using Accurate Rip etc.) !?!?!